Question 1 :D

Woo! Time for round 1! Can you gain the maximum of 100 points?!

Click here if you dont know what is going on!

Ok, the question.

Code:

Should we kill healthy people for their organs?

Why this question, think about this.

Suppose Bill is a healthy man without family or loved ones. Would it be
ok painlessly to kill him if his organs would save five people, one of
whom needs a heart, another a kidney, and so on? If not, why not?

Discuss and answer, remember, 3 sets of points are up for grabs.

Please note you can submit as many answers as you want.

Cheesy.

Killing Bill for his healthy organs sounds like a good idea, but I think the FBI shouldn't just then come in and say 'Die sukka!', Bill should sign an agreement, saying that he agrees that he wants to die because he has no life because Myninjakiwi is getting deleted.


How about that?

killing bill for his organs would probably not be a good idea...
reason:
if someone just killed bill for a persons organs and put them in another person,
the person who needed an organ would most likley die because their body would attack the new organ
The person who needed the organ needs to be testted to see if they are a match.

But if bill and the person was a match bill might not want to donate the organ. he could have a good reason too.

Cheesybanana wrote:

Suppose Bill is a healthy man without family or loved ones. Would it be
ok painlessly to kill him if his organs would save five people, one of
whom needs a heart, another a kidney, and so on? If not, why not?

Think of it this way. If Bill was mortally depressed because he doesn't have a family or loved ones, than he should just go and die. If he so chooses. If he would like to live than the doctors would have to go and murder him. If they did murder him they would have to lure him to a place where he would get totally oblivious to anything and everything around him. To the computer!!!!!! But than Bill was sad because his favorite Soap Opera was cancelled, so he commited suicide anyway. And in the end everyone is happy.

There are alot of reasons of Pros and Cons to killing Bill or anyone else who may have good, healthy organs.


Pros:

1. Killing the one person to bring back a number of people could be a good thing.
2. In a way, they could use other peoples organs of healthy people who did this also and maybe Bill or any other person would just lose organs that aren't needed.


Cons:

1. If they kill the person, there could be ways of not being able to bring back the dead people, results of bad health, and other things.
2. They would give up someones life just to bring back others, that person may be as important to others just as the other people are.



There are 2 pros and 2 cons, but...I say to kill him to bring other people back, it just would sound like a good idea for me.

No, unless bill is poor

Whats that got to do wit anything

no, cuz it is possible to grow new organs that will match a person using his o her T cells

The question explination inclueded that the people had to be dead to donate the organs.

Bill should have say in this.

Bill is already dead by now.

it would be wrong to kill anyone, even if they had organs other people needed. and anyway would people even have permission to kill him? yes thats right, i answered a question with a question. even if it would help 5 other people then i still think it PROBABLY isn't necasery. but you did mention the fact he had no family. but this depends, was he still happy, even without a family? and you also said he was a healthy person. it wouldn't be right to kill a healthy, posibly happy man, would it?

although im not entirely sure, after thinking it through more than carefully, more than half of my brains and wits have some to a final answer of no. . .

stuff bill, if i was dieing of bad health i would just take his lovely healthy organs and be well hopefully better die in hell bill. I mean R.I.P bill

ROUND OVER


POINTS GIVEN

50 points to Brian E for most thought out answer.
25 consulation points to alyrox2009 and Yoshimaster for good answers.

25 points to winkley for making me laugh xD

Not enough intrest was given for a poll, so no points there.

1 DAY DISCUSSION PERIOD BEFORE LOCK

Gratz to everyone who got points.

lol i would definately agree with 25 points for winkley lol, he made me laugh more than a little. Well done briane also fully deserving 50 points for a great answer, i was useless, but what the hell its fun!

Yep Locked!

Wait...

since I have 999 points, can I use them on 2 strike reductions, and the other 10 to a random person pleeze?